Unbinding Abraham
"Mrs. Lincoln and friend"HE CROSSED THE ROOM with a silent stride. Taking yesterday's gazette from the sideboard, he carefully sat down and moved to a chair near the fire. Molly sat staring into the fire at the edge of the davenport, ignoring him. The chair was too small for his frame, and he rustled uncomfortably with the papers in his hand as he too looked away. Glancing at the print, he grumbled at no one in particular, "What good is the news in these broadsheets?" The dispatches had already brought him yesterday's numbers at breakfast; still, rustling through the printed cries of public outrage and the terrible mortality of it all seemed his duty, and oddly, to somehow assuage his private misery.
It seemed the very least he could do was to feel their pain.
Silly dear Puss, he thought, glancing her way. Couldn't she see that his heart was broken too? Couldn't she see that? His Molly, who knew him better than the axe knew the oak? He didn't show it; it was his job not to place his personal grief over the nation's. However, he certainly knew it in almost a Biblical sense of hurt. He shuddered against that hurt, closing it off in some lost corner of his mind and heart lest he go mad.
"Damn it, little woman," he thought. "I'm not like you," he felt as if in the Devil's thrall. "I cannot afford the luxury of missing him!" What right did he have to mourn his boy when so many boys had been forfeit? Honestly, Puss, he thought, you've simply got to understand... There's a damn war going on.
The black cloth of her dressing gown was wet with sorrow. She looked down, away from him and into the fire, half angry at him for the loss of her boy, both blaming and not blaming his ancient face all at once. Her nose raw, she sputtered, "I don't care about your damn war!" She clutched at the salty tears soaked into her handkerchief, unable to get the final images of their boy's gasps for life from her mind. Everywhere her mind turned, there was so much loss; there was no relief from it. He simply cannot understand my loss, she thought. Yet she knew this was not true. It was just the lie she told herself to cover the pain in her own heart.
About that time, a steward they referred to only as Mr. Slade came through asking if they needed anything else before the house took to their beds. He smiled kindly toward the man, telling him no, that they would be fine, though looking back at Puss, he wasn't sure they would be. "Yes, Slade, all's well. Enjoy what's left of your evening," he said. "Give our regards to your goodwife." Molly just turned away further, embarrassed in her grief.
"Slade"
The room went quiet, isolating them. The dim glow of the oil lamp illuminated the fractured paint of the second Mrs. Adams' portrait, suspended over them, and the gentle crackle of the embers fading in the hearth. Breaking the silence, she spoke, "I've asked them back, you know."
Treading lightly for an answer he surely already knew, he replied, "Yes, Little Woman, who have you asked back?" He flattened the gazette against one long leg, creasing its folds with his large fingers against bony knees. Be steady, he thought. She needs you now more than anyone else in this world, though his mind raced with the bloody details of accounts sent back to him this morning's dispatch report.
"Why Margaret Laurie and her daughter Belle, of course," she answered too shortly and with a breathless misery. "You know she saw him last time, but he slipped away before she could hear what he wanted to tell me. Belle was certain he was with us too."
Shifting uneasily, his fingers ceased fiddling with the creases of the broadsheets. Reaching out toward her, he gently touched the fabric of her skirt, quickly withdrawing his hand back as if afraid of burning. "Little woman..." He said, stopping in thought and considering his next words carefully. "Molly, I miss the boy too, but he's departed now, dear. There's no amount of looking for answers from the heavens that's going to bring him back." He instantly recoiled at the delivery of his own words, regretting the terrible truth they contained.
"Oh, you and your accursed war!" Puss sputtered half angrily his way. "You've cared nothing about him nor his memory since he's been gone." She knew she was striking deep at both his public and private pain. "What would I not give for just another brief moment with our boy? Can you not fathom that a mother should want that? Can you not fathom that Margaret Laurie is gifted seer and can reach out to the nether world? Can you not see the possibility that her daughter Belle is but a conduit... a way for us to be with our boy if only for the moment of a brief fare-thee-well? Really, Abraham, why do you torture me so? How can you be so callous?"
"I've no love of spiritists, Puss," he replied. Gently, he went on, "I do not discount universal possibility, nor that there are greater things in God's creation to which we are not privy nor meant to understand. However, the consolations you seek, dear one, are not found by consorting with spiritists the likes of the Laurie women or the Fox girls in the Red Room. Dear Little Woman, these are answers we will only find through introspection and prayer."
His eyes watched as the air seemed to drain out of her.
He knew the practicality of his words had cut. "Have I spoken too plainly?" he thought to himself. The boy's been gone nigh a year now. Perhaps a rail trip to visit cousin Harriet in Cleveland would distract her from this never-ending parade of mediums she sought answers from. He could tell, though, that she was undeterred. There would be no peace for either of them.
"Won't you join us, though dear?" She smiled as if she hadn't heard a word from him at all. It was the smile of the Molly Todd he'd fallen in love with so many years ago. "They'll be here tomorrow evening", she continued, lightly going on. "They've asked that all the mirrors in the house be draped by the time they arrive. Mrs. Laurie said it's done to better engage with the departed so as they don't get lost in their own reflections trying to reach out to us. We'll see to Mrs. Cuthbert removing the mirror coverings after. I've made all the arrangements."
"Darling, I don't think..." He faltered a bit. "I'm expected in Philadelphia the following day. Wouldn't it be a better use of time to take an evening out?" But as he looked her way, he could see that she was lost, so utterly lost in the firelight and alone in the incessant cackle of her mind's quest to get their Willie back or any word from him somehow someway. He glanced up at the portrait of the second Mrs. Adams on the wall. It did not matter to lose this battle with her. The truth was that he could never afford to lose her. In the end, there was little choice. "Yes, Puss, if it brings us closer to our boy, of course, I will join you."
It was then that for a brief moment he watched as the sunlight returned to her eyes.
II.
Margaret Laurie and her daughter Belle were fearless hens, or so he thought as Slade escorted them into the Red Room deftly announcing their arrival. It was half past seven the following evening, and the sun was well set as he paced the floor. Though his mind was certainly elsewhere, Molly had asked him to await their arrival with her, still, his mind was filled with the horrors of the day's field reports. Slade had asked Mrs. Cuthbert to drape the mirrors as Puss had instructed, and everywhere he looked, the room appeared cloaked in a dismal candlelight. The draped mirrors only led to distorted flickers of memory and the unease that the entire room was about to be sent adrift.
The two women arrived dressed in the usual dour gray he'd witnessed before. He winced, hoping the evening's dark light would hide the rebel color of the woman's garb from Slade's discerning glance. The women were accompanied by an unctuous man whom Slade introduced as the woman's husband. Abe only half heard the introduction of a "Mr. Cranston Laurie" as the said man strode past Slade, offering an exaggerated bow to Molly and an unwelcome handshake to him. The man's handshake drew no further friendly reply or reaction from Abe, other than an unwanted coppery taste in his mouth and the feel of butcher's lard at the touch of the man's hand. To his credit, the smarmy fellow read the room and quickly took his place off to the side, nervously stroking the lackluster hairs of his balding head, and allowing "the hens" to get a better sense of what they murmured to Puss as "the intrepid disbelief" in the room.
On Molly's cue, Mrs. Cuthbert asked the two women to be seated in straight-backed chairs arranged near each other in a brief semicircle. She and Abe sat across from them, he in his favorite rocking fiddleback and Puss in a well-worn Queen Anne that no doubt had long ago belonged to the second Mrs. Adams, she, who now watched on with steely enameled eyes from her perch on the wall. An awkward silence ensued, that is until a grief-stricken Molly reached out for Margaret Laurie's hand in a beseeching sign for the elder Laurie woman to begin her spiritualistic reach. As if on cue, Mr. Cranston Laurie retreated further into the shadows still stroking his hairless head, as their daughter Belle began to utter strange sounds under her breath. Belle's sharp dark eyes and ruddy features seemed to begin to undulate, moving against the air like the opening stanza of a well-rehearsed road show.
He felt himself startle at the histrionics of it all, indeed if not the utter evident theater. Before he could say a word, though, practical, polite, or otherwise, he saw Molly's face. Seeing that she'd already fallen into the rapture of the Laurie women's spell, he silenced himself, choosing instead to "rise above" as they say, and return to his inner thoughts, to those of the war, and to where he'd left off in his reading of Marcus Aurelius. After all, he didn't want to upset his Molly when she so badly needed to win this battle within herself and conquer some sort of communication with the ethereal around them.
It was about then that the woman, Margaret Laurie, turned to him and said with the chortle of a fishwife, "I see that you are not a believer, sir."
Slightly abashed, and as his Molly cast her eyes downward, he replied, "I hold no ill will nor forethought of malice toward you, your practice, or your messages, Mrs. Laurie. You are graciously here as I am to support my dear wife's call to the memory of our beloved son Willie."
Mrs. Laurie moved to face him, dislodging the phlegm crowded inside her waddled throat. As she did so, and with that phlegmish sound she made akin to a wolverine's growl, she squinted at Abraham's unease. Raising her eyebrows, she examined him like a midwife or wolf would a newborn; she carefully eyed him for any sign of weakness. Mocking his sincerity with the look in her eyes, she continued on with a soliloquy of her peculiar questions, if not her intent. All in the room was quiet in its restlessness, and still she spoke.
"Have you chosen to win or to lose this war between the brothers of the North and South?"
Abraham straightened his back, angling his long legs out from the seat of the fiddleback. He slowly regarded Mrs. Laurie, scanning her daughter Belle, and, in his periphery, he could see old man Laurie in the background waiting as if ready to pounce on a beggar's dropped penny. They all appeared not to move from their designated positions as he attempted his reply;
"Madame," he began somewhat sternly, "I take neither joy nor umbrage in your question. I pray only that you will understand when I say to you that who will win or who will lose this war is likely beyond the matter of my simple choice. That choice, as you call it, madam, belongs solely to the hearts of our good soldiers and to Providence."
"Is it not your choice, indeed, Mr. Lincoln? She replied, smiling the tidewater grin of a harpy cheating at cards. "It will be the choice of a nation that you will make, will it not? It will be a choice that will bind or divide brothers for centuries to come. Is that not so?"
"Mrs. Laurie, I assure you that I only pray that this union will be preserved," he replied, growing uneasy at her glib nature.
"Listen well to your choice, good sir," she replied, not without some arrogance. "And listen well to the message here tonight. Consider only that, in the end, generations may benefit more from the loss of this war than a win, indeed from the loss of your so-called "union." Consider, sir, that you cannot bind that which does not choose nor wish to be bound."
Abe felt himself grow irritated. Who was this charlatan to first prey on his wife and speak so adroitly without respect or reservation for his office? He recoiled. How had they let this harpy through the door? He wondered if he shouldn't call for Slade and have the harridan and her like expelled from the house. He was in no mood for the simpering rhetoric of not-too-secreted Copperheads, seance or otherwise.
He turned once again to address Mrs. Margaret Laurie, but before he could say another word, a great shout and tumble of words broke out of her daughter. The younger woman, Belle Laurie, had begun to violently sway back and forth in her chair. Her head was cocked back oddly and to the side, and exposing folds of florid fat over the yellowing lace of her collar. Her mouth had fallen open at a peculiar angle too, and the skin of her neck seemed to ripple against the lace of her collar in a sickly yellow contrast against her ruddy pallor. A film coated her upper lip, and her face took on a disturbing mottled hue as her forehead appeared to grow further moistened and damp.
It was, however, not Belle's raw look that caused them all to gasp, but her words that forced them all (and most notably his dear Molly) to shrink back, clutching both Margaret Laurie's hand and her handkerchief to her breast. Even Abraham felt a disturbance in the air around Belle Laurie, but it was Belle's strange words that rang out to him in the dead evening air which brought them all asunder. Words that said...
"Poppa, are you there?"
III.
It was Puss who broke the air first, saying, "Abraham, sit down!!! Can you not see that our boy is here with us? Can you not hear that he is trying to break through to deliver us a message from his long home? I simply can't bear it, Abe. You must stop now!" Mary Lincoln screamed. It was the scream of an agrieved mother, and it shattered the candlelit stillness and spilled out over the mumbling antics of Belle Laurie. Belle Laurie, who, by all accounts, appeared to have entered into the depths of some great fugue or trance.
"Darling boy, it's mummy," Molly spoke as if to the air around her. "Poppa is here too. We miss you so, dearest Willie!" She went on, entreating what she could not see and seeing only what she felt in her mind's heart.
Belle Laurie, seemingly exhausted from her exertions, now sat upright, rigid in her chair and taken up with her fugue. Her eyes rolled oddly "this way and that," and soon she continued on in a voice not quite her own...
"Poppa, it's so cold here. So very cold. There's snow and ice everywhere and no trees or greenery. It's not home, Poppa. I know it's not Virginia. I'm so cold Da, so cold...Oh, Da, why have you sent me here?" It was Willie's voice speaking through Belle Laurie. The voice was heavily distorted, disrupting, with gasps of air that came out in between her efforts to form words. Still, one couldn't be sure who indeed was making them, either words or gasps, or the boy or Belle Laurie.
"Boy, yes, it's me, your Father," Abraham said. "I am indeed here, son." Abe continued, not believing necessarily that he was truly speaking with the departed spirit of his son, but unwilling to gamble on Mary's sanity in that moment.
Molly spoke again, "Darling boy, can you not ask for help or take cover from the cold where you are? Oh, my darling, can you not stay here with us instead, where we can keep you safe and warm?"
Belle Laurie trembled a bit at this, and the voice of Willie Lincoln appeared to reply to both his parents in a question. "Why have you sent me here to see this cold?" he asked. "There are few people here, strange ones, Eskimo-like with dogs and furs, and many are not yet departed as I am. There are great metal birds that rise up and growl through the sky like flying dinosaurs and men dressed in green with helmets like Roman Centurions marching to and fro. I see great belching ships floating among the ice in the seawater. It is all so very cold here, Poppa."
I hear them talking too, Dad. They say that they are soon to be new states in the union. I hear them talking about the numbers 51 and 47. I hear them talking about Russia and China and some place called Panama. They say this is all because of what Lincoln did so many years ago. What can they mean, Father? What did you do so many years ago? They say this is what preserving the union wrought. What does wrought mean, Poppa?? There is a huge flag here planted in the ice, but there are too many stars on it. So many stars all crowded together. Poppa, why are there so many stars on our flag!??! They say that things are becoming unbound. Help me, Poppa! I am so cold. What does it all mean?
Why have you sent me here? Was I bad?
Abe felt a chill go through the room. The chill seemed to come out of no place. He opened his mouth to speak, to reply to the peculiar and ethereal questions the presumed voice of his departed son was asking, but he could summon no words. It was all too incredible. It was all too unimaginable. It broke his heart, these strange things Willie (or Belle) was saying. He watched too as his Molly looked on in horror, entreating the silence that overtook the room for more answers.
There were none. Belle Laurie shuffled; her face regained it's ruddy color and her eyes opened up in a normal fashion. She straightened herself in her chair. Whatever had happened to her, whatever communication there was from Willie or from some icy Great Beyond appeared to have fled.
"Oh no!" Molly cried out gasping and clutching the hand of Margaret Laurie. "Tell me he isn't gone! You must get him back! He's not well, Margaret, and he's so very cold. Oh, please, do ask Belle to summon him again... I will give you anything you wish for, just get my boy back."
As Mary Lincoln sobbed into her handkerchief, Mrs. Cuthbert seemed to appear out of nowhere. Molly Lincoln stood up and, as if on instinct, went over to Cuthbert's comforting embrace. It seemed that the evening was drawing to an end. Abe could tell that Molly was a wreck, utterly drained in her emotions, and he nodded to Cuthbert that she should escort Mary from the room and allow her to retire for the evening. Slade made a sound too, and with crafted motions, both Slade and Cuthbert made efforts to conclude whatever had taken place there in the Red Room.
Slade drew back the heavy curtains over the windows, letting the light from the soldiers' torches outside carry in through the window glass. The night was clear too, and Abraham felt grateful for the stars he could see. Slade lit more candles and stoked the hearth, and even Cranston Laurie moved, moving quickly to assist Belle to recover from her fugue state. In a surprisingly gentle move, Cranston Laurie assisted his daughter Belle by offering her water and shouldering her out into the ante-chamber.
Finally, it was just the President and Mrs. Margaret Laurie.
Abe began. "I'm not sure what you have done here, madam," he said. "But I will not welcome you back into this house again. I have no room in my heart for such cruel shenanigans or tomfoolery against my wife or family. And as to your political countenance, I suggest you take your morbid theater acts back to Hell's Bottom or Murder's Bay where I suspect they might play out for a nickel better." Abraham grimaced, angrier than usual.
Margaret Laurie looked unfettered. Standing up, she appeared to shake free from the wrinkles and folds of her dour clothes but never lost her cold demeanor. She eyed him as Seward once had, or as one would an equal or a rival in business matters. Speaking abruptly and without caution, she said,
"Did you not hear your message, good sir? I did advise that you should."
"What message?" Abe replied with unusual alacrity. "Do you not mean the message you concocted to "cheer" my wife? A message from my dear dead son speaking of giant metal birds growling like dinosaurs and of Eskimos and icy wastelands and of too many stars crowded onto our dear Old Glory? What message would that be, madam, other than the insane showmanship you and yours have attempted to shuck and purvey?
Your "union," my good, sir.
That is the message your own son delivered to you from some far-off place. Did I not tell you that your war will bind that which does not choose or wish to be bound? Indeed, perhaps that which in the end should not be bound? Your union, sir, indeed your war of brothers, binds slavers and abolitionists together. Does it not? It binds Catholic to Quaker, and railroads to cotton? Your union shall bind zealots and charlatans from all walks of life, and thieves to honest men and atheists - and all this in the name of your intended righteousness. Can you not see, sir, that not all things are stronger because of a "union" - that all things will only evolve differently bound or unbound according to their purpose?"
"My good man, there is purpose in our diversity and much consequence in its lack," she sputtered on.
Abe scoffed, "I am not your good man, madam. For that matter, what is your madness, woman? Save your machinations and manipulations for some other sad rube. Is it not time you left this house?"
She laughed, another chortled and phlegmish sort of laugh, but a laugh just the same. "You will only move the post further down the fence line, sir. The boundaries of such things are set forth by God. I see by your colors that, yes, you will win this war, and well, perhaps you should."
"You should, however, not mistake me for a sympathizer or Copperhead, Mr. President," she continued. "I assure you, I am neither. I will only tell you that in winning this war, you only postpone that which must happen because of it - because of your "win." Yes, you will postpone that which must happen. Your "union" will save you and this country from many terrible things for many decades to come. But your winning will create new ones. It will save you from two unimaginable wars with the Germans and thoughts of war with so many others. Your "winning it" will not hide you from these things any more than "your union" might possibly return these blessed shores home to England or France. Sir, as you are both bound and unbound to win or loss no matter. There will come a time too, sir, when your immortality will rise above the memory of your many imperfections. Perhaps then, sir, you shall see that all clocks, union or not, must become unwound."
"All skeins of thread must unwind," she said chiding him. "Consider the consequences of the action for that union and that which cannot be "unbound." In one hundred years, no, I say in two hundred years, would it have been better to leave things, as I said, without any union and unbound?"
"Would it have been better to have lost this war as you lost your dear Willie?"
"Perhaps, sir, your union will create a future Giant Power so large that it will seek to bind other things like Eskimos and Vikings, and to bind them all with giant metal birds that growl like dinosaurs while your union's future Roman Centurions are sent into other icy and cold places owned by others and places that do not wish to be bound? Centurions to take things and places that do not belong to them?"
Stunned, Abraham sat down. Margaret Laurie, smoothing her dress and smugly preening her hair one last time, affected to take her leave. She gave a slight nod to Slade as she walked out. The candlelight caught her wolverine-like sneer as she moved toward the door. "As to your son, sir," he does miss you, you know. It was he who spoke to you, not Belle. Consider only his message."
"After all, it is not he who is bound."
END